News   |   Rates   |   Calculators   |   Community   |   Locations
Mortgage Loans
Money Market Accounts
CDs and IRAs
Credit Cards
Community First Financial Advisors
Investment & Insurance
Insurance Center
StudentSmart Products & Services
Properties for Sale
Member Resources
EMV Chip Cards

How can we help you?

Quick Links

Checking & Savings
Mortgage & Home Equity
Loans & Credit Cards
Auto Buying Service
Investments & Insurance
Become a Member
Community Focus
Ask Us A Question:
Home PersonalInvestment & InsuranceInsurance Center

Community First Insurance Center

Insure your home, auto, recreational vehicles, and more with high quality insurance products from the Community First Insurance Center, a wholly-owned subsidiary of Community First Credit Union.  For over 20 years, we've made it our business to give our members peace of mind by making their insurance experience easy and convenient. 

Independent Insurance Agency Means More Choice
As an independent insurance agency, we'll help you compare property, casualty, and life insurance from highly-rated insurance companies, including:  
  • Acuity
  • Allied
  • Badger Mutual
  • Pekin
  • Progressive
Having several companies to choose from and compare, gives you more options with a single phone call or visit - no need to visit several agencies. 

Making Insurance Convenient and Personal
We're making insurance convenient with extended evening hours that fit your schedule and personal service that is focused on you and your needs.  Plus, when you are insured through the Community First Insurance Center, we'll make payments easy with direct payment options through your Community First accounts. 

Experienced Insurance Agents Focused on You!
You will be backed by a team of agents to help you when you have insurance questions and needs.  Contact any of our agents below to review your insurance needs and for a no-obligation quote!

Licensed Member Insurance Representatives
Top Row: Shannon Wiegman - Insurance Center Manager, Penny Kropp
Second Row: Shawn VandenHeuvel, Mao Her & Jason Munson

Ready to Learn More? Contact us for more information or to request a FREE Quote! 
  • Call
      In the Fox Cities: (920) 738-5474
      Toll-free:  1-800-779-1321 
  • Visit:  Inside Community First Credit Union, 509 N. Richmond St., Appleton, WI  (Map it)
  • FAX: (920) 738-5464
  • Hours:  M-W 8:30am-5pm; Th & F 8:30am - 6pm;
print this page
tell a friend
Resize the font:
Acuity: file a Claim
Allied: file a claim
Badger Mutual: file a claim
Pekin: file a claim
Progressive: file a claim
Wisconsin Commissioner of Insurance
Article: Insurance Reviews Helpful
Young Driver Information
Site Search:   Home    |    Contact Us    |    Site Map    |    Privacy Policy
Community First Credit Union   P.O. Box 1487  Appleton, WI    54912-1487 920.830.7200    1.866.273.2328
Web Design & Content Management System by Cambium Group, LLC